Not a Pillow Pet

Arin has been asking for a Pillow Pet for at least two months.  We had planned to buy the girls each one for our road trip.  However, we waited too long and all of the good ones were sold out.  Andy had seen large stuffed animals at Wal-Mart, so we thought we'd try to pass those off as pillow pets to the girls.  We gave Arin a rabbit and Ella a caterpillar.  Here's how the conversation went:

Daddy:  Look, Arin, we got you a Pillow Pet.
Arin:  That's not actually a Pillow Pet, daddy.
Daddy:  Do you like your Pillow Pet?
Arin:  Yes, I like it, but it's not really a Pillow Pet.
Daddy:  Well, I am going to call it a Pillow Pet.
Arin:  Well, you can call it a Pillow Pet and I am going to call it NOT a Pillow Pet!